Total Economic WealthManaged Account vs. VUL · All tools
Let's Talk

Taxable managed account vs. variable universal life, side by side

Project a managed account after taxes and fees, then enter the VUL illustration for the same client and premiums to compare living value, legacy value and internal rate of return.

Total invested
Managed account value
Managed · after-tax if sold
VUL net cash value
Enter illustration below

Side by side

Same client, same premiums, same point in time.

VUL illustration

Upload the illustration PDF, paste ledger rows, or type values by hand. The file is read inside this browser window. Nothing is uploaded to a server or saved.

%
%
Other carriers: paste ledger rows instead

1 · Paste ledger rows

2 · Match the columns

Tell the tool which pasted column holds each value.

Row key
Key column
Premium
Net cash surrender value
Death benefit
Review or type the ledger by hand

Only have the summary page? Enter values at a few ages (for example 55, 65, 75, 85, 95) and the tool fills the years in between with straight-line estimates, shown in grey italics.

YearAgePremiumNet cash surrender valueDeath benefit

Growth over time

Hover the chart to see values by age.

Managed account value Managed after-tax if sold Total invested

Where the managed account's growth goes

After-tax gain
Annual taxes
Advisory fees
Tax due if sold

Milestones

Values at selected ages.

How it works

Managed account. Each year the portfolio grows at the assumed rate. Part of the growth is qualified dividends and the rest is capital gain. Turnover sells a share of the portfolio every year, realizing that share of all accumulated gains. Dividends and realized gains are taxed annually and the advisory fee is charged on the average balance, both paid from the account.

VUL. Values come straight from the carrier illustration you enter, so cost of insurance, policy charges, fund expenses and surrender charges for this specific insured are already reflected. Run the illustration at the same gross rate as the portfolio growth rate for a like-for-like comparison.

Living vs. legacy. Living value compares what the client could reach while alive. Legacy value compares what heirs receive: the managed account with a step-up in basis at death, against the income-tax-free death benefit. Estate taxes are not reflected on either side.

Year-by-year detail